MES-Validation

MES validation for pharmaceutical manufacturing From recipe to batch.

For manufacturing execution systems used in GMP production. We define the scope with your team, plan testing and give QA the evidence needed for its release decision.

  • The scope follows manufacturing from recipe to batch.
  • Failures, resumptions, and interfaces are also reviewed.
  • You decide on release in accordance with your quality process.
Video in German · Read the English summary

Daniel explains how the team can support an implementation with a fixed go-live date. You agree the scope, roles, milestones and release decisions. The team carries out the agreed validation work and reports progress through to handover.

Integrated Validation Execution. Project Leadership and Implementation End-to-End.

  • PAS-X, PharmaSuite, Opcenter, and others
  • Annex 11 and Part 11 depending on application
  • Fixed prices are possible once the scope is defined.
  • Contact us using the project enquiry form

At a glance

What is MES validation?

MES validation documents whether a manufacturing execution system is suitable for its intended GMP manufacturing use. Assess manufacturing steps, recipe and master data versions, roles, and handovers to equipment, automation and ERP. Together with the resulting batch records, these define the normal workflow and relevant exceptions that need testing.

  • The specific manufacturing process determines the system boundary and the associated testing requirements.
  • Trace the versions of the recipe and configuration to the batch actually executed.
  • Interruption and resumption can be more critical than a further standard run.
  • Technical equipment status and professional batch release decisions must be clearly separated.

What we deliver

  • Define the manufacturing chain, system boundaries, and interfaces with production, engineering, IT, and QA departments.
  • Clarify requirements and risks, assess supplier and integrator qualifications
  • Develop a testing plan and implement the agreed test strategy, including exceptions and retry actions.
  • Prepare documentation in accordance with your SOPs and templates, transfer it, and train your responsible personnel.

Your team’s responsibilities

  • Process knowledge, recipes, and requirements
  • Project decisions
  • The formal release pursuant to your quality process

System boundary

Which manufacturing steps belong in the validation scope?

A MES sits between ERP, automation, and laboratory systems. Validation follows the manufacturing process flow, not the boundary of a single server.

Select a representative product or process family. Track material availability, process initiation, required inputs, execution, exceptions, and subsequent review of records. Document the tasks performed by the MES and those retained at the plant, automation, ERP, or laboratory systems.

Describe manual steps as well. A manual reconciliation performed outside the MES can be highly significant for the entire control chain. It must not be excluded from the project simply because it does not involve a software function.

The following overview serves as an internal reference guide. The relevant transitions within your operation are determined by the requirements and risks associated with your manufacturing process.

Interfaces of a MES based on decision-making and data significance
TransitionDecision to makeAppropriate testing concept
ERP to MESWhich order and which material may be used?Unique assignment with appropriate status
MES as AppendixWhich parameters belong to which execution step?Link between order, value, and actual objective
Attachment to MESWhich measurement is assigned to which batch?Data comparison including required time and context information
Labor and ManufacturingWhen is an evaluation effective?Behaviour in the absence of or altered feedback
MES for evaluationWhich record is complete?Comparison of execution and used output

Sources: [1] [4]

Items under test

What is verified in a MES.

An MES controls the manufacturing process and generates the batch record. It is verified that both elements are appropriate for your process, including in exceptional cases.

Clarify how a released procedure is generated and which status is relevant for a completed batch. The documentation should distinguish between the definition of a procedure and its actual execution.

An MES must support not only an ideal process flow in the intended use environment. Evaluate relevant scenarios such as a skipped step, missing data, invalid input, or failure of a connection. The following overview serves as a standalone planning aid; the selection and depth of assessments depend on the identified risks.

What to test when validating an MES
SubjectWhat to establishPossible evidence
Recipe and master data versionsHow is a workflow approved, and which version applies to a batch?Version relationship between the recipe, configuration and executed batch
Electronic batch recordingDoes the record contain the contents required for review and retention?Review of records against requirements regarding their content
Roles and PermissionsWho is authorized to modify prescriptions, perform steps, intervene, or approve?Testing of authorized and unauthorized access using test accounts
Interruption and ResumptionWhich steps have already been completed and which information remains valid?Status before and after resumption, with pre-defined reaction
Interface between equipment and automation systemsWhich parameters and measurement values belong to which step and which batch?Data comparison including required time and context information
ERP and Laboratory Interface PointsWhich system handles order, material status, and assessment?Unique assignment with appropriate status, even in cases of delayed or repeated submission
Changes and Audit TrailWhich changes are documented together with the rationale, and who reviews them?Recording of changes, person, date, and reason; controlled review
Review and batch decisionWhat information must be available for the review and who is authorized to approve?Complete record suitable for review, with release by the Qualified Person using an electronic signature

Sources: [1] [2]

Supplier evidence

Combine FAT, SAT, and own tests in a meaningful way.

In the MES project, manufacturers and integrators typically already provide tests. The value of these tests depends on what they substantiate for the specific site.

FAT, SAT, or other supplier certifications may provide valuable input. Assess the actual coverage regarding status, environment, and functionalities provided. Differences relevant to future use must be evaluated. A blanket repetition of all tests is equally inappropriate, as is unverified acceptance of existing data.

Determine who clarifies requirements, who prepares tests and who evaluates results. Technical error correction, re-implementation and the treatment of deviations belong expressly in the task planning.

Sources: [1] [3]

Which supplier assessments do you already have for your MES? Include this information in your enquiry.

Schedule first meeting on MES validation

Working with us

So does a MES validation process work with us.

You know in advance the scope of work to be undertaken and the level of involvement required. Each week, you see what has been completed, where risks exist, and which decisions are pending.

IVE
Integrated Validation Execution

Project management and delivery from one team.

  1. Project management

    Commission the project and agree the scope

    You commission the project and we begin with scoping. We document system boundaries, deliverables, assumptions and the work expected from each side.

  2. Involve the responsible people

    Process owners, system owners, QA, IT and the supplier agree who is responsible for requirements, decisions and approvals.

  3. Make progress visible

    We maintain one agreed status for each system. The weekly report shows completed work, risks and upcoming decisions.

  4. Delivery

    Qualify and validate

    We prepare the agreed documents and evidence under your SOPs and templates, with testing and technical review as defined in the project.

  5. Hand over the evidence and knowledge

    We hand over the documentation, record open points and their owners and prepare your team to maintain the system in operation.

Computer system validation at a glanceExplore IT GxP consulting

Results by project phase

What you end up with in your hands.

Each section concludes with a result that forms the basis for the next. Responsibilities are agreed upon with the operator.

SectionTo be clarified jointlyUsable result
ScopeManufacturing chain and boundaries relating to facility, automation, ERP and laboratory systemsJustified scope with data flow diagram and open decision points
PlanningRequirements, risks, recipe and master data versions, and supplier evidenceVerifiable requirements and justified validation plan
ImplementationSystem status, test data, routine processes, exceptions, and findingsAssociated results with evaluated deviations
InterfacesTransfers, Failure Behavior, and RestartEvidence of technical suitability at each transition point
Usage decisionOperational readiness and evaluation of resultsDocumented decision in accordance with the own quality process
OperationRecipe changes, equipment interfaces, updates and reviewResponsibilities and applicable operating procedures

When we use GxPsuite, we draft these documents from your templates in the application. How we work with GxPsuite

Effort and costs

What determines the effort required for MES validation?

We estimate the work once we have agreed the scope and objectives of your project.

Costs of a Computerized System Validation in Detail

Send an enquiry

Checklist

What should be clarified prior to the start of a MES validation.

Twelve points at which offer, planning, and target date can be measured. An open response is initially acceptable, provided it remains visible as an assumption and is assigned to a subsequent clarification step.

System and intended use
Data and evidence
Team and planning

How we work

Every project follows the same quality framework.

Reliable validation depends on who leads the work, which standards the team follows and how the results are checked before they reach QA. We establish the same controls on every project.

Daniel Herrmann provides technical oversight on every project. The team uses consistent procedures, templates and quality checklists so that quality does not depend on one individual.

We specialise in the life sciences: pharmaceuticals, biotech, medical devices and laboratories. Our focus on these sectors gives our team the GxP experience it brings to your project.

  1. Technical oversight

    Provided by Daniel Herrmann on every project.

  2. Consistent procedures

    The same procedures and templates across projects.

  3. Quality checklists

    Defined checks on every project.

  4. Continuous improvement

    We incorporate proven improvements into our procedures and checklists.

GxPsuite, our documentation system

Prepared automatically. Reviewed by experts. Approved by you.

For documentation for your MES validation we use GxPsuite. It brings together your sources and automatically prepares a draft from your templates. Your team can review the draft and see which details still need to be supplied or checked.

Our experts begin their review with a draft prepared from your templates. This reduces manual preparation and helps us produce consistent documentation across projects.

The AI cites the source it used when answering a technical question. Our experts review the draft. Your team checks its relevance to the actual system and makes approval decisions under your quality procedures.

People make the technical decisions.

GxPsuite is a product of traqx GmbH, co-founded and managed by Daniel Herrmann.

Learn more about GxPsuite at gxp-suite.com

  1. 01 / Starting point

    Your sources and templates

    Your procedures, system documentation and a clearly defined task.

  2. 02 / Preparation

    A draft ready for review

    Documents and answers cite their sources and identify outstanding questions.

  3. 03 / Decision

    Experts review. You approve.

    Technical review and approval follow your existing quality procedures.

Personal project experience

Experience relevant to your project

HMS Analytical Software · Daniel Herrmann’s personal project experience

Build CSV processes into an existing quality management system

“Daniel kept our company’s particular circumstances in mind throughout and scaled the processes accordingly.”

Elisabeth Kohm · translated from the published German text
Read the published testimonial

SAP rollouts at Boehringer Ingelheim · Daniel Herrmann’s personal project experience

Coordinate validation management across SAP projects

“Daniel brings tremendous value through his expertise and commitment to validation and compliance.”

Jens Fuellbier · translated from the published German text
Read the published testimonial

ERP implementation at a pharmaceutical company · Daniel Herrmann’s personal project experience

Build CSV capability during a large ERP project

“A patient expert who exceeds expectations and successfully completes even the most complex projects.”

Heidelinde Hecher · translated from the published German text
Read the published testimonial

Daniel Herrmann’s own project work.

Three common misconceptions

What makes a MES validation robust.

Common assumption01

“The manufacturer has conducted the FAT and SAT. This constitutes our validation.”

FAT, SAT, or other supplier certifications may provide valuable input. It is essential to determine the current status, environment, and functionalities associated with them.

What matters in practice

Relevant differences for future use must be evaluated.

Common assumption02

“A error-free standard batch run serves as evidence.”

It can provide significant value, but does not automatically address questions regarding errors or interruptions. Additional checks arise from a risk assessment.

What matters in practice

Select cases that are relevant to your actual process.

Common assumption03

“A “completed” status means the batch is acceptable.”

A "completed" status may indicate that a technical process has ended. Whether records are complete and professionally evaluated remains a separate issue.

What matters in practice

The review requires the full record, including deviations and amendments.

Frequently asked questions

Frequent Questions on MES Validation.

Still have a question?
Send us your question.

Send a project enquiry
Does MES validation cover the connected equipment?

No. The system boundaries and existing qualification or validation documentation must be explicitly evaluated. Interfaces and shared dependencies must be considered together. A complete validation record for the MES application is not automatically equivalent to a complete equipment qualification record.

Sources: [1]

Which regulatory frameworks apply to MES validation?

This depends on the intended use. For computerised systems in GMP-regulated activities, EU GMP Annex 11 is applicable; EU GMP Chapter 4 addresses documentation, including batch manufacturing records. When electronic records or signatures are used within the FDA's jurisdiction, 21 CFR Part 11 applies. GAMP 5 is a guidance document from ISPE and is not a regulation; we use it as a methodological reference.

Sources: [1] [2] [5] [6]

Do we need to repeat each supplier test?

Not at all. Suitable proofs can be used after justified evaluation. Among other things, coverage, version and relation to the own environment are decisive. Insufficiently documented or differently equipped functions may require additional tests.

Sources: [1]

What is particularly important regarding electronic batch records?

The records must support the intended process with appropriate content and context in a traceable manner. This may include version references, assignments, changes, and relevant exceptions. Information required for review and retention should be specified in the requirements.

Sources: [2]

Who is authorized to release a batch in the system?

Where a computerised system records certification and batch release, EU GMP Annex 11 calls for release by the Qualified Person only. The system should identify the person releasing the batch and use an electronic signature for release. Define in the requirements which information that decision needs.

Sources: [1]

Must the entire system be revalidated after every change to a recipe?

The required testing depth arises from the recipe change and its potential impact on the intended use. Therefore, evaluate first which functions and common technical dependencies are affected. From this, the testing activities and documentation adjustments can be justified.

Sources: [1]

What documentation does an external validation partner need?

Process and system boundaries, recipe structure, interface overview, existing supplier certifications, and known open items are helpful. Add planned product or process variants, roles, and test environments. This enables the identification of specific outcomes and the required level of involvement.

What is the cost of a MES validation?

The effort depends on the process families, recipes, master data, plant and system interface points, exception cases, and existing documentation. Fixed pricing is possible once the scope is defined. For ad-hoc consultations, a daily rate may be agreed.

Sources and review date

Sources behind this guide

Source date: November 12, 2026. The regulatory reference framework covers computerized systems in human medicinal product manufacturing, particularly EU GMP Annex 11 and Chapter 4, as well as 21 CFR Part 11 where applicable. Overviews, test objects, and checklists are standalone work aids and do not constitute official regulatory requirements. Product-specific statements are detailed in the linked system guidelines.

Daniel Herrmann
Life sciences compliance specialistSources checked: Updated:
  1. European Commission: EU GMP Annex 11, Computerised Systems, January 2011 revisionPrinciple and No. 1 regarding scope and risk; No. 3 and 4 concerning suppliers and validation; No. 5 on data exchange; No. 9, 10, 12, and 15 relating to audit trail, changes, access, and batch release.
  2. European Commission: EU GMP Chapter 4, Documentation, January 2011 revisionSection 4.20 on the contents of a batch processing record.
  3. European Commission: EU GMP Chapter 7, Outsourced ActivitiesOutsourced GMP-related activities: Suitability, responsibilities, and agreements.
  4. ICH Q9(R1): Quality Risk Management, official text from the European CommissionRisk-driven decisions and appropriate formalities; internal summaries are implementation proposals.
  5. eCFR: 21 CFR Part 11, Electronic Records; Electronic SignaturesSection 11.1 regarding scope; applies depending on usage within the jurisdiction of the FDA.
  6. ISPE: GAMP 5, Second Edition – Public Description of the GuidelineGuideline on risk-based validation; methodological orientation, not legislation.

Services

Computer system validation · Explore this service →

Your project enquiry

Tell us about your project

Tell us about your MES project, target date and the support you need.

Send an enquiryTell us about your project · We reply by email
Daniel Herrmann
Daniel HerrmannWe start with your situation.