Regulations and compliance · Practical guide

Critical thinking in GAMP 5 validation

Your team is deciding whether to run another test. QA wants assurance, IT points to existing results and the process owner needs a working system. GAMP 5 critical thinking brings the discussion back to one question. What do we need to know before using this function? A worksheet and a fully worked example guide that decision.

Table of contents

At a glance

How do you choose the right level of validation evidence?

State the decision you need to make. Consider how the system could fail, what the consequences would be, what you already know and which uncertainties remain. Select and document evidence that addresses those uncertainties. GAMP 5 Second Edition emphasises this approach. Depending on the risk, it can justify either using existing evidence or performing more targeted testing.

  • Define the business decision precisely enough to test.
  • Separate assumptions from established facts.
  • Compare the alternatives by what each can demonstrate.
  • Revisit the decision when new evidence emerges.

What does critical thinking contribute?

ISPE's public description emphasises choosing an approach that fits the case. The public table of contents lists critical thinking in lifecycle section 3.4 and Appendix M12. We developed the worksheet below. It does not reproduce those sections of the paid guide or prescribe a particular form.

Start with the decision. “Is the supplier package enough?” gives the team little to work with. “Does this test show that our configured role can make the permitted status change?” identifies a claim against which the team can assess evidence.

Sources: [1] [2]

Further reading:

Define the question before choosing a solution

Which business decision does the software support? Identify the record, the action and the possible error. Who could detect an incorrect outcome? Could they do so before someone uses the record again?

Ask an open question. “Why do we need no further tests?” assumes the desired answer. “What existing or additional evidence do we need for this transition?” lets the team assess whether it can reuse existing results.

In GMP activities, Annex 11 section 1 calls for a justified, documented risk assessment to determine the extent of validation and data integrity controls. Identify the consequence you need to control and the evidence that will demonstrate this. Calling an activity “critical thinking” supplies no rationale.

Sources: [3] [4]

Separate facts, assumptions and uncertainties

A supplier description and an observation from your own system carry different weight. A supported assumption is also distinct from a system characteristic no one has investigated. Make those distinctions clear before anyone approves use on the strength of an untested assumption.

ICH Q9(R1) links uncertainty, importance and complexity to the appropriate level of formality. A deadline does not make an unanswered question less significant. New information can change the amount or type of testing needed.

Sources: [3]

Can the team demonstrate that a blocked batch stays blocked?

In this example, batch C-17 is blocked in the warehouse. The dispatch function must prevent it from being picked. The supplier has evidence for local status management. The team does not yet know whether an overnight import can overwrite the block in the target system.

The decision concerns how to demonstrate that the block still works after import. It does not require the team to decide whether to revalidate the whole system. The table sets out the available evidence in this fictional example.

What the team knows before choosing a test
StatementEvidence availableImplication for the decision
Batch C-17 is initially blocked. Defined starting condition. Establish and confirm this condition before testing.
The local display shows the block correctly. The supplier has evidence. Its relevance still needs assessment. Compare the version and configuration.
The import preserves the block in the target system. Open question. Examine the import rule and the control that acts in the target system.
Dispatch prevents picking of the blocked batch. Required outcome. No observed result yet. Check what the dispatch user can actually do.

Sources: [4]

What can each evidence option demonstrate?

Retesting the local display would leave the import question open. A configuration review can explain the status mapping. A targeted end-to-end test can show how the import and dispatch function work together in the specified case. Choose the combination in light of the relevant evidence already available.

Document why the team chose a particular option. Record what the alternatives would leave unexplained so another qualified person can review the decision.

Example decision matrix for the batch import
OptionWhat it establishesDecision in this example
Retest the local display Leaves the effect on import and dispatch open. Insufficient for this question.
Inspect the import mapping Explains how the status values map. Include as design or configuration evidence.
Import a blocked batch and try to ship it Tests the required outcome in the business process. Include a targeted test unless suitable evidence already covers this case.
Check only that the import succeeded Does not demonstrate that the block works. Do not accept as the only functional evidence.

Sources: [4] [3]

How should risk influence the test method?

The blocked-batch example needs a defined expected result. Exploratory testing can reveal other ways to bypass the block. An automated test could revisit the same business transition later. Choose each method for the question it can answer.

Neither “scripted” nor “exploratory” describes test quality by itself. Explain how the starting condition, observation, deviations and final assessment can be traced. Greater uncertainty may justify tighter control of a particular test. It does not prescribe one test method for every situation.

Sources: [4] [3]

What makes a short decision record complete?

Record the question, relevant information, chosen evidence and remaining uncertainty. State the conditions under which the decision holds. In this example, the import rule and target configuration must remain unchanged. Reassess the decision if that basis changes.

You need not minute the entire discussion. Explain why another option is insufficient or why repeating a test would add no evidence. Someone reading the record must be able to tell whether a point remains untested or is already covered by suitable evidence.

Sources: [4]

Using critical thinking in a small team

The process owner explains the consequences of a failure. IT describes data flows and configuration. QA reviews the requirement and rationale. An experienced facilitator can help a less experienced team identify assumptions. A large committee is not a general requirement.

Start with a real decision the team has yet to make. Gaps in process knowledge, inaccessible evidence and unclear dependencies increase the work involved. Generic risk statements will not resolve those questions. Ask whether another qualified person can follow the reasoning behind the chosen evidence.

  • Write a neutral question that the team can answer.
  • Identify the requirement and the potential effect of a failure on the process.
  • Distinguish facts, assumptions and unknowns.
  • Check that existing evidence applies to this case.
  • Compare at least the plausible alternatives on their merits.
  • Record the decision, its conditions and the trigger for reassessment.

Sources: [3] [4]

Project experience and collaboration

Identify the question before choosing the document

We start with the substantive question your team still needs to answer. What failure would matter, what is already known and which additional evidence could support the decision? Under clear conditions, an existing test may suffice. If documentation conflicts with actual use, that discrepancy needs investigation first. With the responsible owners, we record the reasoning so a later reviewer can understand both our choice and its limits.

Frequently asked questions about Critical Thinking

Is critical thinking another term for risk assessment?

It also informs how you frame questions, assess information and compare evidence options. A risk assessment provides important inputs. Later project decisions still need a clear purpose and rationale.

Sources: [1] [3]

Can an experienced employee decide alone?

That depends on the decision, the employee’s competence and the responsibilities you have assigned. Experience matters, but the basis for the decision must be clear. Involve the relevant specialists when significant process or technical uncertainties remain.

Sources: [4] [3]

How much documentation do we need?

Enough for another person to follow the question, evidence, decision and relevant conditions. A short note may be sufficient. A complex decision may need more explanation. A fixed page count would say little about what the team needs to establish.

Sources: [4] [3]

Can a deadline justify less evidence?

Time pressure explains a scheduling problem. It does not establish that weaker evidence is adequate. You can use suitable existing evidence or narrow the intended use. Account for the uncertainty that remains.

Sources: [3]

Does a high risk score automatically require a scripted test?

A score alone cannot determine the method. Consider the consequences of failure, what you know, how the controls work and what the test must demonstrate. Some questions need a precise expected outcome. Others also require investigation of unexpected paths.

Sources: [3] [4]

Can existing evidence replace a test of our own?

Yes, if it answers your specific question and applies to your system. Check the function, version and conditions. The fact that evidence came from a supplier does not rule it out or make it suitable by default.

Sources: [4]

What if team members disagree?

Identify the assumption on which they differ. Often a fact about the consequences of failure or the behaviour of the system is missing. Investigating that question will usually help more than voting on generic risk scores.

Sources: [3]

Must every decision be reassessed?

Specify the conditions under which it remains valid. A relevant change or new finding can affect its basis. Evidence for an unchanged function calls for a different response from a decision that relied on a disproved assumption.

Sources: [4]

How can we train a team in critical thinking?

Discuss a real case with incomplete evidence. Ask the team to separate facts from assumptions, compare options and explain a decision. The quality of that explanation tells you more than recall of another checklist.

Sources: [1] [3]

Is the example matrix a prescribed GAMP template?

No. We developed it to make the decision traceable. The public ISPE sources describe the emphasis on critical thinking. They do not prescribe this table. Use a format suited to your process and quality system.

Sources: [1] [2]

Sources and review date

Sources were checked on 6 October 2026. The text identifies the scope and status of each document. The examples and worksheets are our suggestions. Assess their suitability for your process.

  1. ISPE, GAMP 5 Guide, Second EditionPublished in July 2022. The public product description discusses retaining the underlying principles, service providers, iterative and incremental methods, and critical thinking.
  2. ISPE, public table of contents for GAMP 5 Second Edition2022. Sections 3.4, 5, 7 and 8, and the list of appendices.
  3. EMA, ICH Q9(R1) Quality Risk ManagementR1, Corr.2 dated 23 January 2025. Sections 3–5 cover formality, uncertainty, subjectivity and risk-based decisions.
  4. European Commission, EU GMP Annex 11: Computerised SystemsJanuary 2011 revision. Principle and sections 1–4, 7, 9–13 and 17.

Sources checked: .

Daniel Herrmann, Daniel Herrmann Consulting

Daniel Herrmann Consulting

Discuss the decision your team needs to make

We help your team connect the applicable requirement, the actual data flow and the evidence needed for a decision. We start with the records you already have and the question they leave open.

  • GAMP 5 consulting →

    Understand how GAMP 5, EU GMP Annex 11 and 21 CFR Part 11 apply to your systems. We translate the relevant requirements into proportionate validation work and evidence your team can defend in an audit.

Send a project enquiry Customer testimonials →