Table of contents
At a glance
How do you validate a Sage system for GxP use?
Identify the Sage product and the process you intend to use. Assess the version, modules, customisations, interfaces and significance of the data. Use these findings to define requirements, risk-based tests and evidence for your installation. A batch feature or supplier certificate alone does not establish that the installation is fit for GxP use.
- Sage X3 and Sage 100 are separate product lines with distinct operational environments.
- The standard, partner solution, and custom adaptations must be clearly identifiable within the system landscape.
- Testing follows the actual data processing and its significance for the process.
- Evidence and responsibilities must also cover expansions and modifications.
Sage X3 and Sage 100: First determine the specific system in use
"We use Sage" is still too vague for technical planning. The first step is to create a system overview document: product line, version, modules in use, operating mode, locations, and responsible service providers. Additionally, installed add-on solutions and customer-specific customizations must be included. This document enables alignment between functional departments, IT, and the implementation partner on the same set of requirements.
Sage describes X3 as an ERP system for finance, supply chain, and production. The German Sage 100 offering includes, among other features, inventory management, accounting, and production, along with options for customization and enhancements. These statements indicate a potential functional scope. They neither confirm the actual implementation nor verify the suitability of the system for a specific GxP process.
| Product example | Before assessment, clarify | Not to assume generically |
|---|---|---|
| Sage X3 | Version, Locations, Processes Utilized, Enhancements and Integrations | Identical functions and integration pathways across all versions. |
| Sage 100, German product offering | Installed modules, add-on solutions, customizations, and operating modes | That an advertised partner function belongs to the standard of every installation. |
| Connected solutions | Manufacturer, Version, Assigned Task and Processed Data | That the ERP assessment automatically includes scanners, document management system, and interface. |
Which Sage processes are relevant for GxP evaluation?
The scope follows the intended use, not the brand name. If Sage is used exclusively for a commercial transaction, a different question arises compared to its use in material consumption, production, or traceability control. First, it is determined which regulated activity the company performs and what role the system plays within that activity.
EU GMP Annex 11 serves as a central reference point for GMP-controlled activities. The GxP term, however, encompasses a range of different activities and regulatory domains. Therefore, specific operational requirements must be defined prior to the use of an audit checklist.
A useful process mapping traces a data record from origin to decision: Who enters it? Which calculation or transfer alters it? Who reviews the result? What could a wrong information trigger? This also reveals dependencies, for example a product attribute that controls the labeling of a material.
- Consider material and batch identity including assignment to movements.
- Capture quality-relevant status values and the resulting usage decisions.
- List production specifications, relevant calculations, and required traceability.
- Evaluate labels, reports, and exported files based on their actual usage.
Sources: [1]
Formulate requirements such that they are testable
"The system must manage batches" leaves open what must be demonstrated in operational practice. A more precise requirement would specify, for example, which batch identifier is retained during a material transfer, who is authorized to modify it, and how subsequent traceability is achieved. The implementation partner can then assign this technical requirement to an existing function or to a customization.
For risk assessment, potential errors and their consequences are described. Examples include a unit of measure error, loss of batch assignment, or failure to transfer quality status. Appropriate controls and checks are then derived from these considerations. Extensive documentation without a clear link to these risks does not automatically enhance the credibility of the assessment.
The functional area and QA should know in advance what result is acceptable. This ensures that evaluation remains independent of the outcome that may be randomly observed. Requirements, implementation, and testing are assigned clear references. If a later change to an extension is implemented, it will be possible to specifically identify which validation evidence is affected.
Sources: [1]
Include partner solutions, in-house fields, and interfaces
The Sage AppCenter includes additional solutions, such as mobile data capture, document linking, or data exchange capabilities. These offerings are not automatically included in an existing installation. For X3, the developer portal outlines various integration approaches. The specific options available and appropriate for a given scenario depend on the particular application requirements and system configuration.
For each relevant additional product, it is recorded which task it takes over, which data it generates or changes and who takes care of its changes. When a scanner records material movements, the transfer to the commodity management is also considered. If an adapted report template generates a quality-relevant proof, its logic is part of the evaluated process.
Appropriate tests extend beyond error-free standard transmission. This may include an unknown item, an invalid unit, a failed transmission, or a repeated message. Expected behavior and the responsible operator are defined in advance. A failure shall not be considered resolved solely because the technical connection has resumed functionality.
Data integrity: Verify accesses, modifications, and available audit trails
The actual state of play shows which history, signature or archiving functions your installation offers. Therefore, the evaluation begins with the specific data type. In case of a quality-relevant change, for example, the changeable fields, authorised users and available evidence are to be considered.
Separate three questions: Who is authorized to perform an action? How is a subsequent change detected? Who reviews this information in operations? An change log does not replace appropriate rights assignment. Conversely, a role matrix does not confirm whether the desired restriction is effectively enforced in the actual user account.
For external administration and technical users, tasks and authorized accesses are also specified. When performing data exports, it is verified whether the required linkage is preserved: A number without a unit, batch assignment, or processing status may be insufficient for the intended purpose of demonstration. Required data must remain accessible even after changes to the application.
Sources: [1]
Example: Goods receipt using scanner and verifying quality status
The following example describes a test concept for an ERP environment featuring Sage and a mobile add-on solution. It does not constitute a claim regarding a standard feature of Sage X3 or Sage 100. Assume that operations capture items, batch numbers, and quantities at the scanner and transmit the data set to the ERP.
The test begins with known master data and a predefined user role. Upon data entry, the values are compared against those entered in the ERP system. Subsequently, it is assessed whether the resulting inventory balance permits or precludes the intended use. A test case involving intentionally inappropriate input demonstrates how the system handles such scenarios.
Additionally, an interruption in transmission is considered. The operator must be able to determine whether the process has already been recorded and how it is resumed under control. Following repetition, inventories and documents are reviewed for unintentional duplicates. Relevant evidence links scanner input, interface processing, and ERP results through unique identifiers.
| Test case | To be specified in advance | To review thereafter |
|---|---|---|
| Valid data entry | Article, Batch, Quantity and Unit | Consistent dataset in the ERP system. |
| Invalid input | Not allowed value and desired reaction | Expected rejection or controlled processing. |
| Transmission interruption | Detection and Retry Procedures | Traceable processing status without undetected duplicate entries. |
| Change in quality status | Authorized user and intended process impact | Correct status and intended impact on usage. |
Sources: [1]
Data transfer and ongoing Sage systems assessment
In the case of a new introduction or a version change, it is necessary to clarify which data are taken over and which remain available in another system. For planning an overview of source, destination, conversion and verification is recommended. Special attention should be paid to units, date values, status and relationships between datasets.
A technical import log documents the import process. For professional assessment, it is additionally verified whether the result meets the required significance. For example, a received batch may exist, but could be incorrectly assigned to the wrong product or an inappropriate status rule. Identified deviations are evaluated prior to final decision.
For an existing system, the current status is first documented. Existing documentation is reviewed for validity; subsequent modifications and additional solutions must not be omitted. Missing evidence is addressed as gaps through a technical assessment. Systematic supplementation of current documentation does not constitute retrospective justification for prior, unverified use.
Sources: [1]
Prepare documentation and ongoing operation jointly
A clear and comprehensive evidence base demonstrates which system has been evaluated for which intended use. This is achieved by integrating system descriptions, requirements, risk assessments, supplier documentation, and evaluation results. The final assessment outlines findings, deviations, and remaining actions. The document structure aligns with the company's quality management system.
The implementation partner provides key information regarding system setup and customizations. These contributions should be specifically agreed upon: which configuration states are documented, what tests are available, and how future changes will be communicated. A partner relationship does not replace the organization's own technical decisions and responsibilities.
In operation, any modifications to standard software, add-on solutions, and custom adaptations are subject to documented impact assessments. This includes changes to templates, interfaces, and relevant master data rules. The determination of additional testing requirements is based on the affected functions and associated risks. Responsibilities for access controls, outages, data backup, and regular system evaluations are clarified prior to handover.
Sources: [1]
Checklist for preparation of Sage validation
These questions help distinguish a specific proposal from a general ERP evaluation. Missing information serves as a meaningful starting point for a current assessment, not a justification for unsupported assumptions.
- Which product line, version, and modules are actually in use?
- Which additional solutions, customizations, and service providers are included?
- Which regulated processes and quality-related decisions depend on the data?
- Where are relevant data generated, and through which interfaces are they transmitted?
- Which users are authorized to enter, modify, verify, or release data?
- What documentation, test data, and appropriate test access points are available?
- Who decides on deviations, release, and changes during ongoing operations?
Project experience and collaboration
Define what needs testing in your Sage installation
Which Sage solution do you operate, with which modules, extensions and connections? We clarify this with users and IT before defining the tests. For one quality-relevant transaction, we follow the data from the original value to the decision. The assessment may focus on a single add-on or on how several components work together. We reuse existing documentation where it applies to that use.
Frequent Questions on Sage Products and GxP Documentation Evidence
Is Sage suitable for GxP-regulated companies?
Yes, if the specific Sage product, with its configuration, organizational controls, and existing evidence of intended GxP use, is appropriate. Limit and evaluate the used modules, extensions, and data pathways against these factors, and verify that the required controls are in place. A general manufacturer description does not establish the suitability of your installation.
Sources: [1]
Are Sage X3 and Sage 100 validated in the same manner?
The methodological issues relating to requirements, risks, and validation evidence are similar. However, the technical evaluation varies by product line, version, modules, and enhancements. Functions or integration paths of one product line must not be unverified transferred to another.
Does a batch management system provide sufficient evidence of GxP suitability?
No. A batch function serves as a technical starting point. It must be demonstrated that identity, assignment, status, and other required information are correctly processed within the intended process. This includes appropriate authorizations, work procedures, and traceable reviews.
Sources: [1]
Are Sage add-on solutions included in validation?
They are included when they influence the relevant process or its data. This may apply, for example, to mobile data entry, a customized output, or an interface. The scope and review depth follow the specific function and risk assessment, not solely the designation as an add-on product.
Does the Sage implementation partner provide all required validation documentation?
A deployment assignment does not automatically include all validation documentation. Specifically define which product, configuration, and test documentation your partner will provide. Assess the transferability of such documentation to your own process and any additional testing requirements. Technical approvals follow your organization's quality process; they are not replaced by the provision of a partner package.
Sources: [1]
Can a previously implemented Sage system be assessed if incomplete documentation is available?
Yes. First, the current system status, existing documentation, and relevant gaps are assessed. A technical evaluation determines priorities and further actions. Newly generated evidence relates to the actually reviewed state; it does not retrospectively validate an unexamined past.
Sources: [1]
What is the effort required for a Sage validation?
Determine effort primarily based on product line, modules, process variants, expansions, and interfaces. Available documentation and a suitable test access can facilitate preparation. Also plan the involvement and review timelines of functional areas, QA, IT, and partners. Only through joint definition can it be clarified which activities are already covered and which packages remain to be calculated.
Sources and review date
The supplier sources describe product lines and potential expansions. They provide no specific evidence of a deployed installation or general GxP suitability. The scanner example is an independent reference document; therefore, no functional assurance is implied for Sage X3, Sage 100, or any specific add-on solution.
- European Commission: EU-GMP Annex 11, in particular the Principle and Sections 1, 3–5 and 9–12
- Sage Germany: Sage X3
- Sage Deutschland: Sage 100
- Sage AppCenter: Additional Solutions and Partner Products
- Sage X3 Developer Portal: Integration Overview – Choosing the Right Approach
Sources checked: .
Support with evaluation of your Sage system
Daniel Herrmann Consulting supports in clarifying the actual system status and the required scope of evidence. Together with your responsible parties and the implementation partner, we address the agreed-upon scope.
- Computer system validation →
Bring your GxP systems into validated operation, from laboratory software, MES and eQMS to ERP. We define the scope, plan risk-based tests using GAMP 5 and hand the evidence to QA for release.

