Regulations and compliance · Practical guide

GCP certified copies: when can a copy replace the original?

A certified copy in GCP must preserve the meaning of the original record. The trial site, sponsor and archivist need to know the purpose of the copy and the information it must retain. Separate a working copy, a certified copy and the later decision about the original.

Table of contents

At a glance

When is a copy of clinical data a GCP certified copy?

Under ICH E6(R3) Appendix C.2.9, a copy that permanently replaces an essential original should meet certified copy requirements. A dated signature or validated creation process should verify that its content matches the original, including relevant metadata where applicable. The copy must remain usable for its intended purpose throughout the retention period. Whether the original may be destroyed is a separate decision under applicable requirements. Certification alone does not authorise destruction.

  • Verified concurrence and permissible original destruction are separate decisions.
  • Metadata and dynamic properties are included in the comparison, to the extent that they are required.
  • A successful export must also remain usable outside the previous environment.

What does a GCP certified copy establish?

A GCP certified copy is a verified copy of an original. Under ICH E6(R3), it must contain the same information, including relevant metadata where applicable. Verification may be by dated signature or generation through a validated process. A copy can be in another medium. Changing the file format alone neither prevents nor establishes equivalence.

Sources: [1] [3]

First define: read, transmit, or replace the original?

Begin with the purpose of the copy. A printout for review and an archived dataset, upon which the source system is subsequently shut down, carry different risks. Therefore, document which version remains the authoritative source and who continues to have access to it. The label "final" in the filename does not answer this question.

The following decision support is an independent work structure. The actual usage is decisive, not whether the team refers to the document as scan, export, or download.

Which copy is required?
UseQuestion to resolveRelevant evidence
Draft for internal review Is the original completely accessible and relevant? Origin and status clearly identifiable; no unsubstantiated replacement effects claimed.
Submission to another party involved What information does the recipient need for his specific purpose? Scope, identity, and completeness to be verified; remaining source access to be clarified.
Replacement of a paper original with a scan Is content, context, and required attributes fully preserved? Verified copy and documented release process prior to original destruction.
Retirement of a dynamic data source Are relevant functions, relationships, and metadata remain accessible? Demonstrate the equivalence of the substitute inventory including its usability.

Sources: [3] [4]

Completeness extends beyond the visible aspect.

A readable numeric value without a unit, time reference, origin, or associated change history may lose its meaning. Define, based on the data object, which metadata are required. This may include assignment to a test, the significance of a timestamp, a signature linkage, or a traceable correction of an original entry. Not every export must automatically include all technical system data.

Static representations are insufficient as a standalone substitute for dynamic electronic records. When filters, relationships, or reconstruction of the processing workflow are required for interpretation, such features must be retained or made equally available. The EMA distinguishes accordingly between a practical display and the preservation of the underlying dynamic dataset.

Sources: [3] [4]

Further reading:

A signature does not substitute for a traceable inspection process

In the manual process, it must be clearly evident which specific item the approving person actually compared and which copy contains their dated confirmation. This includes a clear inventory reference, the comparison benchmark, and the handling of deviations. A signature under "scan verified" remains insufficient when the page count, attachments, or the verified file are not identifiable.

In the automated workflow, the validated process must have a clearly defined intended use and demonstrated performance under relevant conditions. This includes, for example, multi-page forms, color annotations, two-sided documents, and failed transfers. The definition does not require a manual signature to be appended to every result of a validated process. However, any release procedure your process may include remains a justified process decision.

Sources: [1] [4]

Example: A scan is complete, the data export has not yet been performed.

A trial site intends to transfer a three-page laboratory report and its electronic change history to a replacement system. The report contains a colour-coded correction on page 2. The history shows the original value, the change and its reason. The characteristics listed below define the expected scope for this example.

In the first cycle, all three pages are present, but corrections are not discernible in the black-and-white scan. The export contains only the most recent result value. Both are recorded as open findings. Following a re-digitization and supplemental transfer, the same target scope is reviewed. Only documented resolution enables the intended replacement decision.

Defined target size and findings in the example
ObjectIndependent comparisonFindings from the first passRequired completion
Paper report, pages 1–3 Original with three pages, legible annex references and colored corrections Three pages available; correction intent is lost. Fully recognize and accept corrections, and compare again.
Electronic Results Trail Source view with original and amended values together with reason for change Only the latest value is exported. Historical records and dataset relationships are maintained.
Assignment of both objects Audit, person and report identifier from the source inventory Report ID is correct, history is not yet linked. Establish a clear relationship and verify at retrieval.
Long-term access Retrieval from the designated archive by the authorised trial site Access is only possible via the old system. Demonstrate independent access together with read permission prior to system decommissioning.

Sources: [3] [4]

Originals to be removed only after independent decision-making.

A certified copy does not automatically authorise destruction of the original. Before irreversible replacement, assess retention requirements, trial agreements, national requirements and practical availability. Identify who controls the records. A sponsor archive does not automatically provide the control a trial site needs over its source data.

Therefore, three documentable decisions must be made: the copy is identical to the original; it is suitable for the intended long-term purpose; and the original may be retained under applicable conditions. An open error during archive access may prevent the third decision, even though the content comparison was successful.

Sources: [4] [1]

Further reading:

Upon a supplier change, transfer the usability.

An export directory does not establish successful handover. With the trial site, data management and IT, test attachment links, required viewing software, signature information and relevant metadata outside the former environment. For encrypted records, authorised users must retain their intended access.

A supplier description can help identify an export standard. Check it against the data you actually use. Record which attributes transfer, which remain in the source system and how long that system can reliably provide access.

Sources: [3] [4]

Release checklist for a verified copy

The following points assist in making a specific decision regarding system adoption. Open items are assigned a responsible party and an impact on the intended use. A copy may be suitable for limited reading purposes, although it may not yet replace the original.

  • Original, copy, version, and intended use are clearly defined.
  • Relevant content, context, structure, and required metadata are specified within the scope.
  • Dynamic properties and related documentation are considered.
  • Manual verification or a validated generation process is specifically demonstrated.
  • Deviations, verification and clearance decisions are understandable.
  • The trial site and other authorised users can retrieve the required records.
  • A possible original destruction may be separately assessed for its validity.

Sources: [1] [4]

Project experience and collaboration

Test the copy against its intended future use

With the study and archive owners, we compare selected original records against the proposed copying procedure. We examine attachments, metadata and relationships needed for later use or inspection. Static content may require different handling from a dynamic file. We help verify accuracy of the copy and its continued usability. Whether the original may then be destroyed is a separate decision under applicable requirements. Successful export alone cannot establish permission.

Frequently asked questions about GCP Certified Copy

Is every scan a GCP certified copy?

No. A scan is only considered valid upon appropriate verification against the original document. Complete information and, where relevant, pertinent metadata are essential, not merely resolution. Specify which originals and documents are included and how the correspondence has been verified.

Sources: [1] [4]

Does each copy require a handwritten confirmation?

No. ICH E6(R3) specifies a dated signature or generation through a validated process. An additional manual confirmation may be part of your procedure, but it cannot be universally inferred from this definition for every automated activity.

Sources: [1]

Must internal working copies also be certified?

Not solely because they are used for a meeting or analysis. As long as the primary source remains intact, the use of a copy must be distinguished from the original. Origin and status must nonetheless remain clear to prevent a working copy from inadvertently becoming the decisive, incomplete source.

Sources: [4]

Is a PDF sufficient as a substitute for an electronic dataset?

This depends on the required attributes. A PDF can adequately represent static content. However, dynamic relationships and relevant histories needed for understanding or review must be preserved. The practical readability of a PDF alone does not establish equivalence.

Sources: [3] [4]

What metadata must be retained?

Metadata relevant to content, context, and interpretation. Assess, for example, assignment, time reference, origin, and relevant changes to the specific object. A generic export of all technical fields provides little value when the critical relationship between result, source, and change remains absent.

Sources: [1] [3]

Can paper originals be destroyed thereafter?

Not automatically. Following confirmation, conduct independent evaluation of applicable storage and other requirements, as well as assessment of long-term availability. The EMA-TMF guidelines address the specific case of original destruction. Document this decision prior to the original record becoming irreversibly lost.

Sources: [4]

Who must later be able to access the copy?

Access is needed by those authorised for the task, particularly the trial site for its required records, and by authorities within their applicable scope. Agree actual access as well as storage locations. Revoking a provider account can make an otherwise correct copy unusable.

Sources: [4] [1]

Is a missing annex, despite the correct number of pages, relevant?

Yes, if the annex belongs to the required content. Page numbers only verify part of completeness. Supplement the comparison with attachments, linkages, and significant features. In the audit example, release remains open until the missing relationship is clearly established.

Sources: [4]

Can the software supplier assume responsibility for verification?

A supplier may provide an appropriate process and corresponding validation evidence or carry out agreed activities. However, verify that these address the actual inventory and intended replacement. A general "export" function does not constitute confirmation of the completeness of your specific data transfer.

Sources: [3] [4]

What is the difference from the archiving audit?

The document copy review assesses conformity with the source. The archiving review further includes durability, readability, availability, protection, and accountability during the intended retention period. Both review objectives can be combined; one does not replace the other.

Sources: [4]

Sources and review date

Sources checked on 7 October 2026. ICH E6(R3) Principles and Annex 1 have applied in the EU since 23 July 2025. The final Annex 2 has been published, with an EU effective date of 15 January 2027. The 2023 EMA computerised systems guideline explains GCP expectations and is not an EU regulation. This article covers clinical trials of human medicines. The examples are our working materials. Applicable regional law and trial documents remain decisive.

  1. EMA/ICH: E6(R3), Principles and Annex 1, Step 5Principles and Annex 1, Step 5, effective in the EU from 23 July 2025. See the glossary entry for “Certified copy”, sections 2.12.11–2.12.12 and Appendix C.2.9 on permanently replacing essential original records.
  2. EMA: ICH E6 Good Clinical Practice – current versionStatus page, accessed on 7 October 2026. Principles and Annex 1: EU-effective from 23 July 2025; Annex 2: EU-effective from 15 January 2027.
  3. EMA: Computerised systems and electronic data in clinical trialsFinal Guideline dated 9 March 2023. Sections 4.5, 6.1.2, 6.2.1 and 6.4–6.5; Glossary entry "Dynamic file".
  4. EMA: Content, management and archiving of the clinical trial master fileGuideline dated 6 December 2018, effective from 18 June 2019. Sections 4.1.3, 5.1–5.5 and 6.1–6.2.

Sources checked: .

Daniel Herrmann, Daniel Herrmann Consulting

Daniel Herrmann Consulting

Make copies and transfers traceable

Daniel Herrmann Consulting supports you with scope definition, acceptance controls, and reliable decisions regarding clinical data copies.

  • Computer system validation →

    Bring your GxP systems into validated operation, from laboratory software, MES and eQMS to ERP. We define the scope, plan risk-based tests using GAMP 5 and hand the evidence to QA for release.

Send a project enquiry Customer testimonials →