Practical guides · Practical guide

Building a validation team: linking skills, roles and decision authority

The CSV lead has been appointed and the templates are ready, but projects still stall when knowledge, time and authority sit with different people. Map decisions across process owners, QA, IT and project management to identify existing skills and where outside support would help build the team.

Table of contents

At a glance

What does an effective internal validation team need?

Build the team around the work required by the actual system landscape. Define who writes requirements, assesses risks, creates evidence, reviews results and decides on use. Compare those responsibilities with available skills and capacity. Use training, supervised practice and feedback to address gaps. External specialists can undertake temporary work and transfer knowledge, while operational accountability and decision authority remain clearly assigned.

  • There is no general team size that fits independently of tasks and risks.
  • Skills and decision authority are to be evaluated separately.
  • Templates are only useful when their purpose is understood and applied to the specific case.
  • The transition from external processing to in-house execution requires verifiable results.

What activities actually take place within the company?

Monitor ongoing systems, planned introductions, changes, and known open open items. Enhance operational tasks such as incident assessment and appropriate reviews. Distinguish between recurring work and one-off project peaks. This enables visibility into which skills are required on an ongoing basis and which are needed temporarily.

Name also technical and functional diversity. A team handling only standardized applications can be structured differently than a group managing laboratory, ERP, and production systems. The structure should follow from these responsibilities. A copied organizational setup from a larger company may create inappropriate positions and still leave critical gaps.

Sources: [1] [2]

Describe roles with genuine responsibilities and authorities

Who understands the process, who knows the technical equipment, and who evaluates the validity of a test? These contributions may originate from different individuals. A CSV coordination does not need to perform every task personally, but it should ensure that the relevant interdependencies and open decisions are clearly visible.

Annex 11 section 2 calls for close cooperation among the process owner, system owner, Qualified Person and IT. The process owner is responsible for the business process, while the system owner is responsible for system availability, maintenance and data security. Your organisation may use different job titles. Keep responsibility for each task identifiable.

Chapter 2, Section 2.3 requires clear written responsibilities and sufficient qualifications for designated representatives, along with the avoidance of gaps and ambiguities in overlapping duties. Possession of write access to a form does not automatically confer the technical authority to approve system usage. Similarly, a QA role may require technical explanations to adequately assess evidence of compliance. Collaboration must take into account these information requirements.

Sources: [2] [1]

Further reading:

Build a capability matrix based on observable application usage

The matrix assists in aligning required skills and decision authorities within the team. Discuss who actually possesses the capacity to undertake responsibilities and where support is lacking. This leads to a distribution tailored to your organisation's needs, rather than a predetermined number of separate positions.

Assess existing strengths as well as gaps. For example, an employee may be able to write robust technical test cases but still require support in defining process boundaries. The matrix should lead to appropriate tasks, not merely accumulate training hours.

Build a capability matrix based on observable application usage
AbilityObservable usePossible support structure
Process scope Define a system boundary and its interfaces Common pathway for a procedure
Requirements State clear and required results Review own examples
Risk assessment Consequences and appropriate controls justify Supporting Case Work
Validation planning Select appropriate reference and expected result Joint test preparation
Result evaluation Evidence, gap, and acceptance differ Review actually performed tests
Operation Identify and classify any changes or disturbances traceably. Managed investigation of an operational incident

Sources: [2] [3] [1]

More capacity or other subject matter expertise?

Even with additional external processors, a project may have to wait for a subject-matter decision. Therefore, identify the contributions required from process owners and reviewers. Additional document authors provide little help in addressing this bottleneck as long as the required technical expertise is unavailable.

Plan capacity with specific work outcomes and assumptions. Temporary support may be beneficial during an impending migration. For recurring change assessments, however, a sustainable and permanent responsibility structure is essential. Chapter 2, Section 2.1 requires adequately qualified personnel; the scope of responsibility for an individual person must not create a quality risk. Therefore, avoid the situation where the same individual, while managing daily operations, unobservedly assumes all critical decisions.

Sources: [2]

Select a limited pilot as a common learning and working case.

Select a task with a manageable scope and tangible benefit. This could involve a limited system change, which is jointly reviewed for requirements, risks, testing, and closure. Define who performs the work, who leads, and who evaluates the results.

The pilot should include sufficient real-world decisions without subjecting the team to an exceptionally complex crisis situation. Progress in learning and project validation should be evaluated separately. Appropriate mentoring can support both aspects, but it does not replace operational review and release of the actual results required.

Sources: [1] [2]

Example: The team evaluates a new representative role

Assuming that the internal team will assess changes to an electronic document process in the future, a new representation role will be planned in the pilot. Process Owner describes which decision the representative may make; the Owner system declares technical rights and affected controls. Employees derive permitted and not allowed actions as well as required evidence.

External oversight requests open assumptions and provides feedback with rationale. Internally responsible roles assess actual results. In the next appropriate case, the team takes initiative in preparation and coordination and conducts targeted review. If further foundational knowledge is needed, the learning pathway is adjusted. This example does not describe a general qualification based on a fixed number of exercises.

Sources: [2] [1]

Link external assistance with a specific handover

Agree on which capabilities and outcomes should be developed internally. This includes clear decisions, appropriate examples, and access to relevant documentation. Transferring large files without explanation may create a new dependency on the original author.

Define when increasing autonomy becomes evident. For example, the internal team can prepare an appropriate change independently and specifically identify open questions. The external contribution can then be limited to review or specialized tasks. The appropriate transition depends on experience, available resources, and actual scope of responsibilities.

Sources: [4] [2]

Further reading:

How progress within the team can be identified

The number of written documents is not a sufficient metric. Consider, for example, whether requirements are clear, whether recurring review questions are being addressed, and whether changes are being processed with appropriate justification. Such feedback requires context: the identification of a previously overlooked significant finding may indicate more thorough work.

Regularly review task portfolios, competency gaps, and capacity. In the event of a changing system landscape, additional specialization may become necessary. A successful team structure is achieved when responsible personnel can clearly perform their tasks and recognize the limits of their own capabilities.

  • Identify actual tasks and peak workloads.
  • Separate out authority, knowledge, and available time.
  • Assess capabilities at specific application.
  • Conduct a manageable pilot with appropriate feedback.
  • Develop external support following a verifiable handover.

Sources: [2] [1]

Project experience and collaboration

Build a validation team around the work ahead

We review the upcoming system tasks and skills already available in your team. A knowledge gap, insufficient time and a lack of decision-making authority require different responses. A suitable pilot project lets staff practise and shows what they can already do independently. External support can then focus on the tasks that still require specialist knowledge or additional capacity.

Frequent Questions on Establishing a Validation Team

How many personnel are required for a validation team?

A general figure is not feasible. The range of responsibilities, system complexity, changes, and contributions from other areas determine the required scope. First identify tasks and bottlenecks. Only thereafter can an appropriate internal and external workload distribution be planned.

Sources: [2]

Must QA prepare all validation documents themselves?

Who creates a document shall be determined based on the task, required competence, and applicable quality procedures. The Department and IT provide essential inputs for this. Chapter 2, Section 2.3 requires clearly defined tasks without gaps or ambiguous overlaps. The responsible roles for review and decision-making must have the appropriate information and authorities.

Sources: [1] [2]

Can an external service provider fully replace the team?

He can provide extensive agreed contributions. However, business decisions and operational responsibility must still be appropriately structured. A request lacking available internal point of contact may result in significant gaps or delays.

Sources: [4] [1]

Is a training package sufficient for team assembly?

Training can serve as a important foundation. For specific tasks, additional practical experience and an assessment of application are advisable. Prior knowledge and areas of responsibility may vary significantly. Therefore, assess competence not solely based on attended sessions.

Sources: [2]

How do we prevent a permanent reliance on consultants?

Define clear results, supported self-work, and specific handover criteria. Assess at appropriate tasks what can already be independently handled internally. External support can then be more effectively targeted toward remaining specialized or review tasks.

When is a pilot unsuitable?

When scope, risk, or time pressure precludes sufficient guidance and evaluation, it may prove overly demanding for initial engagement. Select a task involving real but manageable decisions. An exercise project must not substitute for the necessary controls of actual usage.

Sources and review date

Primary source date: 17 October 2026. Chapter 2 establishes sufficient capability, resources, and clear responsibilities within the human medicinal product GMP environment. Competency matrix, pilot approach, and example are internal organizational tools. No prescribed team size, fixed implementation deadline, or general competency certification is claimed.

  1. European Commission: EU GMP Annex 11, Computerised Systems, January 2011 revisionHuman medicinal products – GMP; in particular, §§1–4, 7, 10–13, 16–17; specific application for each section.
  2. European Commission: EU GMP Chapter 2, Personnel, effective from 16.02.2014Personal, role-specific training and assessment of practical effectiveness; official EudraLex entry with original chapter.
  3. ICH Q9(R1): Quality Risk Management, official text from the European CommissionRisk-driven decisions, appropriate formalities, and handling of subjectivity; own matrices are implementation proposals.
  4. European Commission: EU GMP Chapter 7, Outsourced ActivitiesOutsourced GMP-related activities, suitability, responsibilities, agreements, and monitoring.

Sources checked: .

Daniel Herrmann, Daniel Herrmann Consulting

Daniel Herrmann Consulting

Compare responsibilities and existing capabilities

Provide a system overview, upcoming initiatives, and known bottlenecks. From this, it can be determined which roles should be strengthened and which specific responsibilities are suitable for a supported onboarding approach.

  • Computer system validation →

    Bring your GxP systems into validated operation, from laboratory software, MES and eQMS to ERP. We define the scope, plan risk-based tests using GAMP 5 and hand the evidence to QA for release.

Send a project enquiry Customer testimonials →